Motilal Oswal Vs RKSV Securities Vs Trade Smart Online

Motilal Oswal Vs RKSV Securities Vs Trade Smart Online


Background

Company Year of Incorporationcontact No.Exchanges enabledDemat (NSDL/CDSL)
Motilal Oswal1987022-30896680NSE, BSE, MCX-SX, MCX & NCDEXNSDL,CDSL
RKSV Securities 2008 – Retail operations from 2012 022-61309999 NSE, BSE & MCX NSDL- Partnership with ILFS
Trade Smart Online 2009 022-42878000 NSE, BSE CDSL

 

Financial Health

COMPANYProfit after Tax FY11/12Profit after Tax FY12/13PROFIT AFTER TAX FY13/14 Profit after Tax FY 14/15
Motilal OswalRs 87.3 CroresRs 89.0 CroresRs 18.4 CroresNA
RKSV Securities– Rs 16.17 LakhsRs 24 lakhsRs 68.7 LakhsNA
Trade Smart OnlineRs 4 LakhsRs 17 LakhsRs 23 LakhsNA

 

COMPANYDebt FY11/12Debt FY12/13Debt FY13/14Debt FY 14/15
Motilal OswalRs 43.9 CroresRs 2.9 CroresRs 6.08 CroresNA
RKSV Securities00Rs 1.38 Crores0
Trade Smart OnlineRs 8.7 LakhsRs 6 LakhsRs 3.05 CroresNA

 

COMPANY Balance Sheet Size FY11/12 Balance Sheet Size FY12/13 Balance Sheet Size  FY13/14 Balance Sheet Size  14/15
Motilal Oswal15.8812.282.72NA
RKSV SecuritiesRs 6.2 CroresRs 15.1 CroresRs 27.9 CroresNA
Trade Smart OnlineRs 9.26 CroresRs 9.28 CroresRs 22.35 CroresNA

 

COMPANYProfit to Equity(%) FY11/12Profit to Equity(%) FY12/13Profit to Equity(%) FY13/14Profit to Equity(%) FY 14/15
Motilal OswalRs 997 CroresRs 1277 CroresRs 1353 CroresNA
RKSV Securities(3.48)5.10(13.73)NA
Trade Smart OnlineRs 304 CroresRs 296.15 CroresNANA

 

Brokerage

CompanyEquityEquity FuturesEquity OptionsCurrency FuturesCurrency OptionsCommodity
Motilal Oswal0.05% for Intraday & 0.5% for Delivery – Reduces upto 0.015/0.15% if brokerage paid upfront0.05% – Reduces upto 0.015% if brokerage paid upfrontRs 70/lot – Reduces upto Rs 30/lot if brokerage paid upfront0.05% – Reduces upto 0.015% if brokerage paid upfrontRs 20/lot0.05% – Reduces upto 0.015% if brokerage paid upfront
RKSV SecuritiesRs 20/executed order per intraday equity, Equity delivery freeRs 20/executed orderRs 20/executed orderRs 20/executed orderRs 20/executed orderRs 20/executed order
Trade Smart OnlineYearly Plan: Rs 10000, Monthly Plan: Rs 1000/month , Normal : Rs 10 per executed order or 2.5% whichever is lowerYearly Plan: Rs 10000, Monthly Plan: Rs 1000/month , Normal : Rs 10 per executed order or 2.5% whichever is lowerYearly Plan: Rs 10000, Monthly Plan: Rs 1000/month , Normal : Rs 10 per executed order or 2.5% whichever is lowerYearly Plan: Rs 10000, Monthly Plan: Rs 1000/month , Normal : Rs 10 per executed order or 2.5% whichever is lowerYearly Plan: Rs 10000, Monthly Plan: Rs 1000/month , Normal : Rs 10 per executed order or 2.5% whichever is lowerNA

 

Account Opening Costs

COMPANYTrading onlyTrading & DematCommodity
Motilal OswalNAFree, but with Margin ChequeFree, but with Margin Cheque
RKSV SecuritiesRs 250Rs 460Rs 250
Trade Smart OnlineNARs 975 for 3 in 1 AccountRs 555

 

Transparency & other costs

CompanyEquityFuturesOptionsCommodities AMC charge AMC charge AMC charge
Motilal Oswal0.00325% of Turnover0.00200% of Turnover0.051% of Premium Turnover0.0025% of TurnoverFreeRs 20/Debit TransactionNIL
RKSV Securities0.0035% on Turnover0.0021% on Turnover0.059% on Premium Turnover0.0036% on Contract turnoverTrading: 0, Rs 400/year for DematRs 22/debit transactionRs 25/order placed on the phone
Trade Smart Online0.00325%0.0035%0.07%0.004%Rs. 400Rs.15 within DP Rs.25 Outside DPRs 25

 

Platforms

COMPANY SoftwareWeb/HTML 5Mobile
Motilal Oswalyesyesyes
RKSV Securitiesyesyesyes
Trade Smart Onlineyesyesyes

 

Charting & Reporting

CompanyIntradayEnd of DayCoding/BacktestingOnline Trade ReportsOnline PNL ReportsOnline Contract Notes
Motilal Oswal3 Months – Pay Extra for Falcon10 years – Pay Extra for FalconNoYesYesYes
RKSV Securities22 days10 yearsNoYesYesyes
Trade Smart Online5 days on NOW10 days on NOWNoYesYesyes

 

Margins(Leverage Provided)

CompanyEquityEquity FuturesEquity OptionsCurrency FuturesCurrency OptionsCommodity
Motilal OswalUpto 10 Times for Intraday, & For Delivery Upto 3 times @24%/AnnumUpto 2 times for intradayNAUpto 2 times for intradayNAUpto 2 times for intraday
RKSV SecuritiesUp to 20 times for intraday, 0 for deliveryUp to 4 times intraday leverageBuying no leverage, Shorting up to 4 times leverage intradayUpto 4 times for intradayBuying no leverage, Shorting up to 4 times intraday leverageFreedom Plan, Pro Plan, ultimate brokerage.
Trade Smart OnlineUp to 5 times for intraday, 0 for deliveryUp to 2 times intraday leverageNo MarginUp to 2 times for intradayNo MarginNo Margin

 

Support & Tools

Company Research & Tips Brokerage CalculatorMargin CalculatorBracket orders & Trailing StoplossTraining & Education
Motilal OswalYesNoNoNoYes
RKSV SecuritiesNoYesYesYesYes
Trade Smart OnlineYesNoNoNoYes

 

Convenience

COMPANY 3 in 1 AccountInstant Fund withdrawalRelationship Managers
Motilal OswalYesYesYes
RKSV SecuritiesNoNoNo
Trade Smart OnlineYesNoYes