Tata Securities vs Zerodha vs Trade Smart Online

Tata Securities Vs Zerodha Vs Trade Smart Online


Background

Company  Year of Incorporation contact No. Exchanges enabled Demat (NSDL/CDSL)
Zerodha 2010  0120-6633205  NSE, BSE, MCX-SX & MCX CDSL
Trade Smart Online 1994 as VNS Finance & Capital 022-42878000 NSE, BSE CDSL
Tata Securities 2007 1800 209 9111 NSE, BSE CDSL & NSDL

 

Financial Health

COMPANY Profit after Tax FY11/12 Profit after Tax FY12/13 PROFIT AFTER TAX FY13/14  Profit after Tax FY 14/15  Profit after Tax FY 15/16  Profit after Tax FY 16/17
Zerodha Rs 2.3 Crores Rs 5.8 Crores Rs 10.27 Crores NA  Rs 44.2 Crores  Rs 88.4 Crores
Trade Smart Online NA NA NA NA
Tata Securities Rs 15.6 Crores Rs 9.8 Crores Rs 11.9 Crores Rs. 4.4 Crores Rs 1.6 Crores Rs 14.5 Crores

 

COMPANY Debt FY11/12 Debt FY12/13 Debt FY13/14 Debt FY 14/15 Debt FY15/16 Debt FY 16/17
Zerodha 0 0 0 NA  0  0
Trade Smart Online 0 0 Rs 1.38 Crores 0
Tata Securities Rs 3.9 Crores Rs 9.58 Crores Rs. 4.1 Crores Rs. 14.3 Crores Rs 9.7 Crores 0
COMPANY Profit to Equity(%) FY11/12 Profit to Equity(%) FY12/13 Profit to Equity(%) FY13/14 Profit to Equity(%) FY 14/15 Profit to Equity(%) FY15/16 Profit to Equity(%) FY 16/17
Zerodha 152 244 147 NA  169  168
Trade Smart Online NA NA NA
Tata Securities 77.73 59.81 37.84 47.3  13

 

COMPANY  Balance Sheet Size FY11/12  Balance Sheet Size FY12/13  Balance Sheet Size  FY13/14  Balance Sheet Size  FY14/15  Balance Sheet Size  FY15/16  Balance Sheet Size  16/17
Zerodha Rs 25.4 Crores Rs 64.5 Crores Rs 111.1 Crores NA  Rs 417.8 Crores  Rs 1072 Crores
Trade Smart Online NA NA NA NA
Tata Securities Rs 56 Crores Rs 101 Crores Rs 203 Crores Rs 69.7 Crores Rs 45.8 Crores Rs 20.4 Crores

 

Brokerage

Company Equity Equity Futures Equity Options Currency Futures Currency Options Commodity
Zerodha Freedom Plan, Pro Plan, ultimate brokerage. Freedom Plan, Pro Plan, ultimate brokerage. Freedom Plan, Pro Plan, ultimate brokerage. Freedom Plan, Pro Plan, ultimate brokerage. Freedom Plan, Pro Plan, ultimate brokerage. Freedom Plan, Pro Plan, ultimate brokerage.
Trade Smart Online Upfront Schemes :Unlimited for Rs 999/PM, Rs 5555/year, Rs 9999/Lifetime, Rs. 9 per Trade Plan Upfront Schemes :Unlimited for Rs 999/PM, Rs 5555/year, Rs 9999/Lifetime, Rs. 9 per Trade Plan Upfront Schemes :Unlimited for Rs 999/PM, Rs 5555/year, Rs 9999/Lifetime, Rs. 9 per Trade Plan Upfront Schemes :Unlimited for Rs 999/PM, Rs 5555/year, Rs 9999/Lifetime, Rs. 9 per Trade Plan Upfront Schemes :Unlimited for Rs 999/PM, Rs 5555/year, Rs 9999/Lifetime, Rs. 9 per Trade Plan Upfront Schemes :Unlimited for Rs 999/PM, Rs 5555/year, Rs 9999/Lifetime, Rs. 9 per Trade Plan
Tata Securities Intraday – 0.02%, Delivery – 0.2%, Upfront charges might apply 0.02% of turnover, Upfront charges might apply Rs 35/lot, Upfront charges might apply 0.02% of turnover, Upfront charges might apply Rs 35/lot, Upfront charges might apply NA

 

Account Opening Costs

COMPANY Trading only Trading & Demat Commodity
Zerodha Free Free Free
Trade Smart Online Free Lifetime Demat maintenance Charges : 700/- Free
Tata Securities NA Rs.500 NA

 

Transparency & other costs

Company Equity Futures Options Commodities  AMC charge DP Transaction Charge Offline order placing Charge
Zerodha 0.00325% on Turnover 0.0021% on Contract Turnover 0.053% on Premium Turnover 0.0025% on Contract turnover Rs 200/year Rs 14 per debit instruction Rs 20 per executed order
Trade Smart Online 0.0035% on Turnover 0.0028% on Turnover 0.06% on Premium Turnover 0.0036% on Contract turnover Trading: 0, Rs 400/year for Demat Rs 22/debit transaction Rs 25/order placed on the phone
Tata Securities 0.00325% of Turnover 0.0019% of Turnover 0.05% of Turnover NA Rs 200/year 0.04% or Rs 25 – whichever is higher 0

 

Platforms

COMPANY  Software Web/HTML 5 Mobile
Zerodha yes yes no
Trade Smart Online yes yes no
Tata Securities yes yes Yes

 

Charting & Reporting

Company Intraday End of Day Coding/Backtesting Online Trade Reports Online PNL Reports Online Contract Notes
Zerodha 365 days on Zerodha Pi 10 years on Zerodha Pi Yes Yes Yes yes
Trade Smart Online 22 days 10 years No Yes Yes yes
Tata Securities 7 days, Annual charge of Rs 500 extra 30 days, Annual charge of Rs 500 extra No Yes Yes Yes

 

Margins(Leverage Provided)

Company Equity Equity Futures Equity Options Currency Futures Currency Options Commodity
Zerodha Up to 20 times for intraday, 0 for delivery Up to 7 times intraday leverage Buying no leverage, Shorting up to 7 times leverage intraday 2 times intraday leverage Buying no leverage, Shorting up to 2 times intraday leverage 2.5 times intraday leverage
Trade Smart Online Upto 10 times for Intraday, & 0 for Delivery Upto 5 times for Intraday No Leverage buying, Shorting Intraday upto 2 times Upto 2 times for intraday No Leverage buying, Shorting Intraday upto 2 times Upto 5 times for Intraday
Tata Securities Intraday upto 10 times, Delivery upto 3 times for interest Upto 3 times for intraday NA Upto 3 times for intraday NA NA

 

Support & Tools

Company  Research & Tips  Brokerage Calculator Margin Calculator Bracket orders & Trailing Stoploss Training & Education
Zerodha Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Trade Smart Online Yes Yes No No No
Tata Securities Yes No No No Yes

 

Convenience

COMPANY  3 in 1 Account Instant Fund withdrawal Relationship Managers
Zerodha No No No
Trade Smart Online No No No
Tata Securities No No Yes